Employer-focused case commentary on Staged2Sell Ltd v Turner [2026] NZERA 724 and [2026] NZERA 819
Employers do not have to tolerate an employee secretly assisting a competing business, soliciting valuable business relationships or working against the employer’s interests while continuing to receive their salary.
That is the clear message from two recent Employment Relations Authority determinations involving Staged2Sell Limited and its former employee.
This was an employer victory. Robert Thompson of I R Thompson Associates, assisted by Graeme Nelson, represented Staged2Sell Limited in successfully enforcing its employment agreement and obtaining penalties and a substantial costs award against the former employee.
In Staged2Sell Ltd v Turner [2026] NZERA 724, the employer established breaches of the employee’s conflict-of-interest and non-solicitation obligations, together with a breach of her duty of fidelity. The Employment Relations Authority ordered the employee to pay the employer $5,000 in penalties.
In the subsequent costs determination, Staged2Sell Ltd v Turner [2026] NZERA 819, the employee was ordered to pay a further $5,375 towards the employer’s costs, together with the $71.55 Authority filing fee.
The decisions demonstrate what employers can achieve when they use a well-drafted employment agreement, act promptly and enforce obligations designed to protect their business.
What happened?
Staged2Sell Limited operates a residential home-staging business. Ashliegh Turner was employed in an increasingly senior position and ultimately became its Home Staging Customer Relations Manager. Her position gave her knowledge of the business’s operations and commercially important relationships with real estate agents who regularly referred vendors requiring home-staging services.
While Ashliegh Turner remained employed, her husband began establishing a competing home-staging business. A website and Facebook presence were created, promotional flyers were distributed and Ashliegh Turner’s telephone number appeared on the competing business’s website. She also became a shareholder in the competing company without disclosing that interest to her employer or obtaining the permission required by her employment agreement.
The competing business received work associated with real estate agents who had previously referred business to Staged2Sell Limited. On one occasion, Ashliegh Turner also used a day of paid leave to help her husband complete a staging job for the competing operation.
When the employer raised concerns and commenced an investigation, Ashliegh Turner resigned.
The value of an I R Thompson employment agreement
Staged2Sell Limited used an employment agreement prepared by I R Thompson Associates. The agreement contained the provisions the employer was able to enforce, including obligations addressing conflicts of interest and non-solicitation. Those protections allowed the employer to establish contractual breaches and obtain penalties.
Ashliegh Turner disputed that she was bound by the replacement employment agreement. Its general execution page had not been signed in the conventional manner. However, she had initialled every page, signed the final appendix, commenced the more senior role described in the agreement and accepted the corresponding increase in remuneration.
The Authority found that this conduct demonstrated acceptance. The employee could not accept the position and remuneration offered under the agreement while rejecting the obligations attached to it.
The result highlights two important points for employers. First, an employment agreement must do more than record pay, hours and leave entitlements. It should contain practical protections addressing the risks created by the employee’s role, including conflicts of interest, outside activities, solicitation, confidential information and competition. Second, employers should ensure that agreements and variations are properly signed before an employee begins a new or altered role. Staged2Sell Limited succeeded in establishing acceptance, but a properly signed agreement would have removed the need to argue that preliminary issue.
The undisclosed conflict of interest
The I R Thompson employment agreement required Ashliegh Turner to obtain permission before becoming a director, shareholder or employee of another organisation.
The Authority found that she breached this requirement by becoming a shareholder in a competing company without disclosure or permission. It rejected the suggestion that the employer had authorised the competing operation during an earlier telephone conversation.
No separate penalty was imposed for this particular breach because Ashliegh Turner subsequently arranged to be removed as a shareholder and the competing business ceased trading during the three-month restraint period. The Authority regarded those steps as meaningful mitigation.
The finding nevertheless confirms the value of a properly drafted conflict-of-interest provision. An employer can legitimately require an employee to disclose an interest in another business, particularly where that involvement may conflict with the employee’s responsibilities or expose the employer’s customer relationships to risk.
Soliciting and diverting business
The employer’s central claim concerned solicitation. Ashliegh Turner knew which real estate agents regularly referred staging work to Staged2Sell Limited. Her telephone number appeared on the competing business’s website, flyers promoted its services, and agents with existing connections to the employer became aware of and used the competing operation.
The Authority found it implausible that Ashliegh Turner and her husband did not know that her telephone number had been placed on the website. It concluded that the activities amounted to solicitation and, in one instance, diversion of business.
The Authority imposed a $4,000 penalty for breach of the non-solicitation provision, payable to Staged2Sell Limited.
Deterrence was an important consideration. The employer had placed considerable trust in a senior employee and was entitled to expect that she would not disregard her contractual obligations while helping to establish a competing operation.
The decision demonstrates the commercial value of a properly drafted non-solicitation provision. This is particularly important where an employee develops close relationships with customers, clients, suppliers or referral partners as part of their employment.
Working for a competitor while on paid leave
Ashliegh Turner accepted that she helped complete a staging job for the competing operation while taking paid leave from Staged2Sell Limited.
The Authority found that she took leave for one stated purpose but used the day to work for a competing business. That conduct was inconsistent with the loyalty required by the employment relationship and breached her implied duty of fidelity.
A further $1,000 penalty was ordered, also payable to the employer.
An employee does not have unrestricted freedom to work against an employer’s interests simply because the activity occurs outside ordinary hours or while the employee is on leave. During employment, employees remain subject to their employment agreements, the duty of good faith and the duty of fidelity.
The employer obtained a substantial costs award
Ashliegh Turner argued that the employer’s costs award should be reduced. The Authority rejected that argument and applied for the relevant starting tariff of $4,500 for the first investigation day. Because further evidence and written submissions were required after the investigation meeting, it added a quarter-day allowance of $875, producing a costs award of $5,375.
The Authority found that the employer’s success was not minimal. The established breaches involved serious conduct, including soliciting the employer’s business and working for a competitor while still employed without transparency. Much of the evidence was intertwined and could not sensibly be separated.
The employee’s unsuccessful argument that she had not accepted the second employment agreement also occupied a significant part of the investigation. This provided further support for maintaining the tariff-based award.
Ashliegh Turner was ordered to pay $5,375 towards the employer’s costs and $71.55 for the Authority filing fee for the one day hearing and the supply of helpful legal submissions.
Combined with the penalties determination, the employee was ordered to pay Staged2Sell Limited a total of $10,446.55:
- $4,000 for breaching the non-solicitation provision;
- $1,000 for breaching the duty of fidelity;
- $5,375 towards the employer’s costs; and
- $71.55 for the Authority filing fee.
What employers should learn from this victory
The determinations show that employers can obtain meaningful consequences where an employee establishes or assists a competitor during employment. Success will depend on the strength of the employment agreement, the fairness of the investigation and the quality of the available evidence.
Use employment agreements that protect the business
An employment agreement should be tailored to the employee’s position and the commercial risks associated with that role. Depending on the business and the employee’s responsibilities, the agreement should address:
- actual and potential conflicts of interest;
- secondary employment and outside business interests;
- direct and indirect solicitation;
- diversion or acceptance of customer business;
- confidential information and intellectual property;
- company property and electronic records;
- post-employment obligations; and
- the employee’s duty to protect the employer’s interests.
Staged2Sell Limited was able to rely on the conflict-of-interest and non-solicitation provisions in its I R Thompson employment agreement. Those clauses provided a clear contractual basis for the successful claims.
A clear warning for employees
These determinations provide a strong warning to employees considering setting up or assisting a competing business.
An employee cannot assume that involvement in a spouse’s or associate’s business is separate from their employment. Becoming a shareholder, promoting the competing business, supplying contact information, approaching referral sources or helping perform competing work may breach the employment agreement and the employee’s continuing duty of fidelity.
Resigning after the conduct is discovered does not remove liability for breaches committed during employment.
In this case, the employee was ordered to pay the employer $5,000 in penalties and $5,446.55 in costs and filing fees, a total of $10,446.55. The employer also obtained formal findings that the employment agreement was binding and that the employee had breached her conflict-of-interest and non-solicitation obligations and her duty of fidelity. Most importantly, the Employer was entitled to show its former employee and others that contracts and good behaviour remain an important component.
I R Thompson Associates assists New Zealand employers with employment agreements, conflicts of interest, suspected competition, misuse of confidential information, customer solicitation, workplace investigations and Employment Relations Authority proceedings. Early advice is important because electronic, social-media and commercial evidence can be altered or lost once an employee resigns or access to business systems is removed.
Case references
Staged2Sell Ltd v Turner [2026] NZERA 724.
Staged2Sell Ltd v Turner [2026] NZERA 819.